We are a small town Catholic Christian gift store with high quality religious gifts for Baptism, Reconciliation, First Communion, Confirmation, Weddings, and Funerals. 

We also have a wide variety of gifts to fulfill any and all of your gift giving needs for Babies, Valentine’s Day, St Patrick’s Day, Easter, Teacher Appreciation, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Birthdays, Anniversaries, Christmas, House Warming gifts, or any other Special occasion.


Funeral Delivery


FREE Funeral Home Delivery to any Funeral Home in Putnam County.
We also offer delivery to surrounding  counties for a minimal fee.

Customer Appreciation Week

Always the last week in September!

Without you and the grace of God, we would not be here. In appreciation, all customers will receive 10% OFF entire purchase (some exclusions may apply).


Monday – Closed

Tuesday, Thursday, & Friday – 9 a.m. – 5 p.m.

Wednesday – 12:00 p.m. – 8:00 p.m.

Saturday – 8:00 a.m. – 1:00 p.m.

Sunday – Closed

***Look for the Red, White, and Blue OPEN flag on our porch***




It’s all about GOD’S TIMING!!

Mustard Seed Gift Shop was originated in 2000 by Alice Recker. Change of ownership took place in March, 2017. Julie Barlage and Brenda Maag do not look at Mustard Seed Gift Shop as a business, but rather a ministry… a way to evangelize to God’s people. It is a privilege to be able to serve our community. Our mission is to help you get to heaven!




Gift Registry

Because you want everything to be just perfect…We offer Gift Registry!  Bring in your First Communicant.  Register for your Bridal or Baby shower.  Register for your Wedding.  Register for any special occasion!

Special Orders

Sometimes it can be challenging to find that perfect gift.  Do you have something in mind?  Let us special order for you from one of our trustworthy vendors!

Baptismal / First Communion Dresses

We carry a large selection of quality Baptismal outfits and First Communion Dresses.  You will find handsome boys christening outfits for your little man and sweet dresses for your princess at amazing prices!

Our Featured Items.


Outdoor Lighted Rosaries

Outdoor Nativity Sets

Infinity Crosses


Stepping into the Mustard Seed Gift Shop is like stepping into a wonder-filled classroom of our beloved Catholic faith:  Inspiration is everywhere!  From books and devotionals to Baptism gifts and nativity sets, I have found everything I needed—and things I didn’t know I needed!  And if it’s something unusual I am looking for, the owners and staff go to great lengths to find it for me.  They are knowledgeable, friendly, faith-filled and fun to work with.

Mary Beth W.

The Mustard Seed Gift Shop provides a wide range of religious items great for personal use and perfect for gift giving.  A hands-on experience when shopping for books, rosaries, toys, journals, jewelry, statues, and more provides the opportunity to select the perfect gift.

Although it’s a rare occurrence to not find what I am looking for, when it happens, the staff is quick to offer other solutions or when time permits, order items for me.  They also know their inventory well, which helps me to find what I need when in a hurry.

This shop is a go-to not just for celebration of the sacraments, but also for the celebration of birthdays, anniversaries, and friendships.  When visiting the store, you are guaranteed to be greeted with a smile and leave with one too.

Jill A.

I am so grateful that our community has The Mustard Seed!  Whenever I want to dig a little deeper in my faith, I can always find the perfect book.  The Mustard Seed is also the perfect place to find gifts for my loved ones & friends.  I appreciate having a place to purchase gifts that will bring Jesus into our homes!

Stacey B.

Get in Touch.

Want to get in touch?  We’d love to hear from you!  Here’s how you can reach us…

Mustard Seed Gift Shop

150 Church Street
PO Box 178
Glandorf OH 45848

Call Us:

419-538-7220 (Store)
419-303-5366 (Julie)
419-235-3106 (Brenda)

Fax Us:

(419) 538-7011

4 + 10 =